According to the release:
Adds experimental PostgreSQL support
The code was written by Cursor and Claude
14,997 added lines of code, and 10,202 lines removed
reviewed and heavily tested over 2-3 weeks
This makes me uneasy, especially as ntfy is an internet facing service. I am now looking for alternatives.
Am I overreacting or do you all share the same concern?
You must log in or # to comment.
Fuck, I love ntfy, it’s one of the best self hosted push notification systems I’ve used. It has been flawless so far.
Don’t like this.
Definitely time to find an alternative. What the actual fuck is this
This doesn’t make me uneasy. It makes me resentful, a little angry, and a lot tired. Thanks for bringing it to attention, I will make sure that nothing of that project or from that author will ever cross my ecosystem again.
You’re gonna have a lot of hate in your blood if you go around acting like the most skilled engineers aren’t using AI to write code.
Most skilled engineers, and even mildly skilled engineers don’t use slopgenerators to write code. Some of them use it sometimes to do some menial tasks, although I’m not convinced it actually saves them time. It sure doesn’t every time we measure it.
There is however a plague of low skilled people who convinced themselves that they’ve found a shortcut to being an engineer. Those people are producing bad things at a fast pace, and the only reason we’re not in an unsolvable crisis yet is that their slop isn’t hitting prod very often on account of being bad.Lol you can definitely generate a large amount of non slop and if you keep believing that then you’ll never see it as a tool to multiply your skills on.
That’s concerning. If it was “I generated a function with an LLM and reviewed it myself” I’d be much less concerned, but 14k added lines and 10k removed lines is crazy. We already know that LLMs don’t generate up to scratch code quality…
I won’t use PostgreSQL with ntfy, and keep an eye on it to see if they continue down this path for other parts of ntfy. If so I’ll have to switch to another UP provider.
I’m so tired of that.
I’m using it for scripts notifications + unifiedpush. I don’t know where to start to find the fitting alternative.
The maintainer you and said that they tirelessly tested, reviewed and verified changes over the course of 3 weeks to make sure that things were running and operating correctly.
This is how it should be done. It’s not like they’re vibe coding this.
Uovote and comment on: https://github.com/binwiederhier/ntfy/issues/1645
Please add this to the post.
I’ll embrace the inevitable fork.
I just set up a ntfy server for Unified Push earlier this week to use with Matrix. Now I have to turn around and immediately replace it…
Well now I certainly am glad I didn’t migrate from Gotify as I’ve been slowly planning.
Lot of hate for a project maintained by a volunteer and offered for free here. Nobody forces this free stuff on you.
Im quite hesistant with idea of AI writing my code. At one point your AI wont help you with fixing certain bug and you will have to go through all of this AI slop. Not to mention you deploy debt code.
In reality how big of a risk it currently is? I just started to use it just for fun and personal projects. If previous version didn’t have security vulnerabilties then then there is no rush to update or am i missing something?
Well, Telegram does the something for free.
What’s the difference between ntfy (android app) and ntfy.sh?
